I think you'll find the following interesting. I was playing with StratFan's card numbers in my database program and came up with some interesting figures. Below you'll find batters' SOM Card Avg, Oba, Slg and OPS with a couple of other things thrown in. This is what the players would hit if all rolls came off the hitter's card ONLY. I figured BP-HR and BP-S using a neutral park (1-10). OPS = On Base + Slugging A quick and pretty accurate measure of offensive performance Rate = (.3*OPSvLH)+(.7*OPSvRH) Approximately 30% of all plate appearance come vs. LH pitching. Bval = Rate * Plate Appearances PosR = Position Ranking by Bval These numbers are not meant to be the final world on player values. They do not factor in fielding, stealing, and all the other things which affect play results. Like I said before, I found them interesting and thought you might too. (Especially with all the non-game crap recently being discussed.) All in all, the numbers are very useful. If you want an all encompassing rating scheme, I suggest purchasing Vince Velten's Lineup program. If you're just looking for offensive value, this table works pretty good. In any event, purchase either StratFan's Rating Book or Lamanna's Rating Book. The measly fee they charge is well worth all the work they put in helping the Strat-O-Matic community. Check out the third base ranking to find a surprise player at the top. NOTE: The following table appears best at 800x600. I suggest cutting and pasting into your favorite word processor or spreadsheet if you have trouble viewing the whole table. Catchers vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR LA Piazza .500 .574 .918 1.493 .492 .548 .973 1.521 1.513 957 1 TEX Rodriguez .365 .382 .546 .928 .350 .392 .539 .931 .930 603 2 PIT Kendall .343 .458 .535 .993 .344 .491 .548 1.039 1.025 586 3 NYM Hundley .172 .480 .368 .848 .313 .408 .778 1.187 1.085 551 4 CLE Alomar .406 .418 .687 1.105 .380 .392 .715 1.107 1.106 531 5 ATL Lopez .415 .485 .624 1.109 .331 .381 .739 1.120 1.117 518 6 FLA Johnson .335 .421 .716 1.137 .234 .376 .492 .868 .949 459 7 SEA Wilson .348 .396 .706 1.102 .226 .283 .306 .589 .743 418 8 PHI Lieberthal .226 .319 .528 .848 .232 .318 .472 .789 .807 412 9 TEX Leyritz .328 .502 .496 .998 .265 .401 .325 .726 .808 367 10 HOU Ausmus .231 .281 .358 .639 .304 .369 .420 .789 .744 356 11 SD Flaherty .282 .388 .464 .852 .300 .313 .374 .687 .736 350 12 MIN Steinbach .323 .392 .507 .899 .205 .242 .330 .572 .670 326 13 BOS Hatteberg .173 .310 .347 .658 .313 .377 .506 .883 .815 322 14 BAL Hoiles .209 .421 .492 .914 .259 .417 .388 .805 .838 322 15 CIN Oliver .298 .377 .368 .745 .257 .306 .494 .800 .783 302 16 MTL Fletcher .228 .249 .531 .781 .287 .306 .608 .914 .874 292 17 CHC Servais .300 .319 .474 .794 .250 .271 .357 .628 .678 288 18 SF Johnson .246 .253 .353 .606 .293 .300 .585 .885 .801 279 19 NYY Girardi .221 .300 .262 .562 .256 .277 .338 .615 .599 259 20 TOR Santiago .342 .348 .607 .956 .191 .214 .317 .531 .658 241 21 MIL Matheny .246 .281 .398 .679 .190 .251 .305 .556 .593 211 22 CHW Fabregas .264 .270 .314 .584 .236 .244 .272 .515 .536 206 23 COL Manwaring .178 .208 .203 .411 .163 .264 .238 .502 .475 178 24 DET Casanova .224 .354 .232 .586 .229 .265 .244 .509 .532 178 25 First Basemen vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR HOU Bagwell .280 .514 .612 1.126 .369 .532 .984 1.516 1.399 1003 1 CHW Thomas .458 .554 1.234 1.787 .448 .596 .796 1.392 1.511 981 2 STL McGwire .305 .498 .985 1.483 .293 .437 .949 1.386 1.415 930 3 SEA Martinez .339 .530 .467 .996 .449 .607 .816 1.423 1.295 878 4 CLE Thome .293 .411 .450 .861 .319 .534 .965 1.499 1.308 820 5 COL Galarraga .385 .510 .821 1.331 .351 .423 .672 1.095 1.166 786 6 NYY Martinez .268 .336 .550 .886 .342 .415 .828 1.243 1.136 778 7 BOS Vaughn .428 .544 .878 1.422 .337 .447 .661 1.108 1.203 755 8 SF Snow .113 .262 .195 .457 .369 .480 .820 1.300 1.047 667 9 LA Karros .228 .321 .420 .741 .315 .385 .642 1.027 .942 659 10 CHC Grace .389 .480 .514 .994 .367 .490 .513 1.002 1.000 654 11 NYM Olerud .270 .466 .542 1.008 .317 .444 .567 1.011 1.010 636 12 DET Clark .255 .352 .515 .867 .272 .394 .552 .946 .922 628 13 BAL Palmeiro .156 .211 .478 .689 .280 .373 .569 .942 .866 600 14 TOR Delgado .242 .332 .454 .787 .255 .352 .711 1.062 .980 583 15 ATL McGriff .272 .394 .427 .820 .301 .379 .543 .921 .891 571 16 MIL Nilsson .211 .240 .255 .495 .337 .429 .645 1.074 .900 566 17 KC King .251 .438 .664 1.102 .179 .323 .439 .762 .864 559 18 MTL Segui .358 .453 .602 1.055 .356 .398 .613 1.011 1.024 536 19 ANA Erstad .326 .382 .564 .946 .308 .366 .441 .807 .849 514 20 MIN Molitor .399 .455 .486 .940 .322 .347 .458 .805 .846 505 21 SD Joyner .261 .302 .467 .769 .408 .469 .565 1.033 .954 494 22 NYY Stanley .347 .505 .659 1.164 .318 .425 .612 1.037 1.075 446 23 SEA Sorrento .145 .232 .365 .597 .279 .339 .623 .962 .853 437 24 BOS Jefferson .133 .157 .142 .299 .419 .435 .628 1.063 .834 437 25 TOR Carter .292 .306 .502 .807 .148 .203 .314 .517 .604 403 26 PHI Brogna .113 .121 .185 .306 .269 .276 .545 .821 .666 387 27 FLA Conine .251 .334 .436 .771 .241 .381 .461 .843 .821 383 28 TEX Stevens .234 .256 .454 .710 .320 .320 .568 .888 .835 379 29 PIT Young .406 .422 .754 1.177 .316 .347 .641 .988 1.045 378 30 NYY Fielder .129 .411 .195 .606 .287 .386 .522 .908 .817 347 31 DET Hamelin .139 .347 .332 .679 .283 .389 .553 .942 .863 319 32 CIN Perez .301 .392 .783 1.175 .237 .301 .497 .798 .911 301 33 STL Young .266 .306 .355 .661 .237 .329 .305 .634 .642 242 34 CIN Morris .234 .248 .267 .515 .297 .331 .392 .722 .660 240 35 1st Basemen vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR HOU Biggio .424 .590 .750 1.340 .374 .513 .624 1.137 1.198 891 1 MIN Knoblauch .327 .465 .423 .887 .320 .452 .507 .959 .938 671 2 BOS Valentin .232 .360 .453 .814 .387 .438 .629 1.067 .991 638 3 SEA Cora .415 .469 .697 1.166 .304 .369 .470 .839 .937 608 4 LA Young .293 .371 .414 .785 .300 .410 .454 .864 .840 603 5 MTL Lansing .343 .410 .597 1.007 .303 .355 .557 .912 .940 593 6 DET Easley .222 .301 .474 .775 .293 .450 .544 .994 .928 576 7 SF Kent .205 .301 .426 .727 .268 .336 .609 .945 .880 573 8 PHI Morandini .355 .505 .433 .937 .326 .394 .438 .833 .864 553 9 STL Deshields .283 .369 .445 .815 .321 .372 .485 .858 .845 543 10 ANA Phillips .251 .466 .369 .835 .279 .419 .352 .771 .790 512 11 CHW Durham .214 .265 .229 .494 .307 .391 .400 .791 .702 499 12 PIT Womack .343 .380 .369 .748 .268 .288 .411 .699 .714 492 13 BAL Alomar .240 .304 .271 .574 .462 .517 .713 1.230 1.033 485 14 BOS Frye .366 .407 .604 1.011 .345 .375 .499 .874 .915 405 15 MIL Loretta .230 .366 .289 .655 .329 .391 .490 .881 .813 392 16 KC Offerman .423 .471 .633 1.105 .272 .319 .351 .671 .801 377 17 ANA Alicea .225 .304 .276 .580 .223 .438 .430 .868 .782 368 18 MIL Franco .232 .438 .232 .670 .289 .394 .354 .749 .725 366 19 OAK Spiezio .203 .284 .441 .725 .213 .242 .294 .536 .593 350 20 CHC Sandberg .303 .348 .540 .888 .237 .258 .335 .594 .682 327 21 CLE Fernandez .497 .516 .740 1.256 .212 .227 .284 .511 .734 325 22 NYM Baerga .085 .094 .149 .242 .344 .350 .461 .811 .640 319 23 LA Guerrero .240 .240 .406 .645 .347 .347 .479 .826 .772 293 24 TEX Cedeno .242 .298 .292 .590 .282 .315 .478 .792 .732 291 25 CIN Boone .137 .337 .246 .583 .206 .257 .289 .547 .557 279 26 TEX McLemore .265 .340 .341 .681 .238 .331 .300 .631 .646 258 27 NYY Sanchez .284 .291 .397 .688 .288 .294 .383 .678 .681 252 28 ATL Lemke .259 .348 .399 .747 .214 .257 .270 .527 .593 235 29 MIL Vina .227 .263 .300 .563 .272 .306 .305 .610 .596 207 30 TOR Garcia .117 .125 .231 .356 .209 .217 .319 .535 .482 183 31 TOR Duncan .180 .195 .202 .397 .216 .231 .267 .498 .467 166 32 3rd Basemen vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR LA Zeile .285 .411 .472 .883 .320 .440 .660 1.099 1.034 695 1 COL Castilla .409 .442 .839 1.281 .301 .340 .573 .912 1.023 683 2 ATL Jones .224 .296 .351 .647 .363 .440 .699 1.139 .991 673 3 PHI Rolen .302 .451 .468 .919 .313 .440 .574 1.014 .985 647 4 FLA Bonilla .466 .486 .797 1.283 .300 .410 .463 .873 .996 645 5 SD Caminiti .357 .441 .560 1.000 .305 .433 .642 1.075 1.053 606 6 CLE Williams .297 .310 .892 1.203 .253 .288 .483 .771 .901 573 7 NYM Alfonzo .467 .556 .654 1.210 .332 .431 .383 .813 .932 558 8 ANA Hollins .395 .462 .643 1.105 .271 .366 .321 .687 .812 526 9 MIL Cirillo .225 .347 .298 .645 .305 .408 .447 .855 .792 524 10 DET Fryman .322 .379 .491 .870 .262 .310 .438 .748 .784 515 11 BAL Ripken .250 .319 .368 .688 .284 .356 .400 .756 .736 505 12 KC Palmer .223 .244 .484 .728 .249 .304 .475 .778 .763 452 13 PIT Randa .268 .356 .362 .719 .368 .438 .534 .972 .896 447 14 CIN Greene .045 .248 .087 .335 .259 .369 .562 .930 .752 435 15 MIN Coomer .475 .475 .671 1.146 .256 .256 .361 .618 .776 427 16 STL Gaetti .299 .383 .546 .930 .235 .278 .383 .661 .742 411 17 SF Mueller .323 .429 .486 .915 .330 .417 .426 .842 .864 391 18 SEA Davis .267 .315 .499 .814 .279 .299 .577 .876 .857 389 19 TOR Sprague .232 .331 .563 .894 .180 .279 .275 .553 .656 368 20 HOU Spiers .206 .427 .340 .767 .395 .530 .577 1.107 1.005 357 21 NYY Boggs .385 .442 .502 .944 .299 .396 .444 .840 .871 355 22 CHC Orie .230 .294 .309 .604 .310 .412 .507 .919 .824 342 23 SF Lewis .324 .356 .542 .897 .264 .305 .475 .780 .815 303 24 NYY Hayes .366 .460 .700 1.160 .187 .278 .297 .575 .750 299 25 MTL Strange .233 .255 .250 .505 .237 .307 .567 .875 .764 284 26 OAK Magadan .175 .327 .175 .502 .365 .512 .495 1.007 .856 281 27 HOU Berry .237 .258 .401 .659 .286 .372 .504 .876 .811 274 28 PIT Sveum .128 .265 .279 .544 .281 .307 .510 .817 .735 249 29 OAK Brosius .048 .101 .057 .158 .174 .235 .279 .514 .407 214 30 Centerfielders vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR SEA Griffey .270 .310 .638 .948 .354 .426 .933 1.359 1.236 870 1 STL Lankford .334 .407 .932 1.340 .325 .500 .738 1.238 1.268 717 2 NYY Williams .396 .542 .838 1.379 .374 .432 .594 1.026 1.132 669 3 BAL Anderson .297 .420 .492 .913 .306 .441 .503 .944 .935 651 4 MTL White .268 .288 .715 1.003 .314 .345 .561 .907 .936 597 5 ATL Lofton .398 .420 .498 .918 .398 .498 .494 .993 .970 547 6 DET Hunter .266 .347 .416 .763 .285 .358 .372 .730 .740 546 7 ANA Edmonds .279 .366 .437 .803 .318 .400 .613 1.013 .950 542 8 COL Burks .275 .356 .463 .818 .304 .407 .753 1.161 1.058 505 9 SD Finley .258 .265 .416 .681 .248 .296 .562 .859 .805 495 10 CLE Grissom .251 .300 .476 .776 .251 .313 .333 .646 .685 426 11 NYM McRae .297 .336 .475 .811 .186 .306 .291 .598 .662 423 12 LA Nixon .199 .251 .289 .540 .285 .378 .296 .674 .633 415 13 SF Hamilton .229 .307 .322 .629 .277 .384 .404 .789 .741 392 14 MIL Williams .284 .297 .509 .807 .223 .237 .339 .576 .645 388 15 BOS Bragg .215 .309 .333 .642 .240 .324 .345 .669 .661 387 16 CHW Cameron .202 .365 .429 .794 .272 .414 .480 .894 .864 385 17 TEX Goodwin .282 .302 .333 .635 .226 .276 .318 .594 .606 385 18 CHC Johnson .325 .369 .455 .824 .351 .405 .439 .844 .838 380 19 CIN Sanders .339 .357 .405 .762 .263 .318 .399 .717 .730 372 20 KC Damon .230 .273 .273 .546 .288 .341 .366 .707 .658 345 21 MIN Becker .025 .180 .036 .216 .296 .400 .416 .816 .636 324 22 PIT Allensworth .291 .462 .432 .894 .230 .336 .318 .654 .726 316 23 NYM Everett .150 .189 .248 .436 .240 .282 .453 .735 .646 314 24 LA Butler .365 .377 .420 .797 .292 .417 .320 .737 .755 303 25 COL McCracken .204 .293 .275 .568 .331 .437 .416 .853 .767 288 26 OAK Mashore .308 .494 .485 .978 .202 .402 .238 .640 .742 254 27 PHI Cummings .209 .290 .262 .552 .258 .327 .418 .745 .687 241 28 TEX Buford .230 .266 .334 .600 .142 .245 .217 .462 .503 203 29 Leftfielders vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR SF Bonds .344 .526 .841 1.367 .333 .519 .814 1.333 1.343 927 1 CLE Justice .392 .454 .886 1.339 .404 .509 .787 1.296 1.309 762 2 TEX Greer .359 .483 .621 1.104 .379 .460 .621 1.081 1.088 751 3 CHW Belle .333 .444 .683 1.128 .283 .323 .580 .904 .971 681 4 FLA Alou .425 .532 .895 1.428 .305 .401 .542 .943 1.089 674 5 DET Higginson .329 .410 .621 1.031 .308 .405 .564 .969 .987 615 6 KC Davis .394 .461 .793 1.254 .242 .382 .564 .946 1.038 589 7 OAK Giambi .329 .441 .594 1.035 .312 .369 .562 .931 .962 566 8 COL Bichette .256 .291 .545 .835 .352 .370 .570 .940 .909 546 9 NYM Gilkey .334 .476 .813 1.289 .215 .339 .341 .680 .862 523 10 ANA Anderson .313 .319 .369 .689 .332 .338 .409 .747 .730 483 11 BAL Surhoff .302 .334 .391 .726 .281 .314 .510 .824 .794 473 12 BOS Cordero .308 .320 .444 .765 .292 .306 .456 .761 .762 464 13 ATL Klesko .123 .220 .298 .518 .293 .352 .670 1.022 .871 454 14 HOU Gonzalez .245 .343 .348 .690 .263 .358 .363 .721 .712 449 15 ANA Henderson .254 .551 .462 1.012 .219 .458 .308 .767 .840 428 16 PIT Martin .280 .406 .454 .860 .317 .361 .549 .910 .895 427 17 CHC Glanville .296 .309 .344 .654 .369 .381 .486 .866 .803 409 18 NYY Curtis .362 .504 .639 1.143 .275 .376 .532 .908 .979 399 19 MTL Rodriguez .147 .242 .350 .592 .218 .247 .588 .836 .762 399 20 TOR Cruz .256 .331 .543 .875 .216 .281 .587 .868 .870 385 21 PHI Jefferies .385 .407 .598 1.005 .212 .293 .300 .593 .716 380 22 STL Gant .133 .237 .363 .600 .222 .316 .382 .698 .669 376 23 CLE Roberts .376 .388 .473 .861 .300 .345 .399 .744 .779 365 24 SD Vaughn .212 .453 .644 1.097 .164 .304 .328 .631 .771 325 25 MIN Cordova .168 .253 .531 .784 .250 .299 .427 .726 .743 307 26 FLA Eisenreich .209 .333 .223 .556 .297 .343 .419 .761 .700 232 27 Rightfielders vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR COL Walker .345 .447 .655 1.103 .480 .557 1.079 1.637 1.476 980 1 CLE Ramirez .460 .540 .801 1.341 .410 .525 .714 1.239 1.269 826 2 LA Mondesi .345 .424 .676 1.100 .408 .424 .770 1.195 1.166 781 3 ANA Salmon .308 .494 .639 1.133 .328 .452 .602 1.053 1.077 749 4 SD Gwynn .425 .431 .736 1.166 .460 .470 .621 1.091 1.114 725 5 SEA Buhner .333 .531 .834 1.365 .168 .406 .540 .947 1.072 713 6 FLA Sheffield .402 .690 .959 1.649 .237 .506 .484 .990 1.188 691 7 NYY O'Neill .274 .348 .418 .766 .394 .472 .670 1.142 1.029 656 8 MIL Burnitz .286 .345 .471 .816 .295 .425 .801 1.226 1.103 637 9 TEX Gonzalez .317 .336 .870 1.206 .318 .331 .704 1.034 1.086 629 10 BAL Berroa .429 .514 .674 1.188 .260 .390 .476 .866 .963 624 11 CHC Sosa .263 .290 .687 .976 .225 .254 .469 .723 .799 554 12 NYM Huskey .415 .415 .728 1.143 .300 .300 .626 .926 .991 500 13 HOU Bell .222 .258 .308 .566 .351 .435 .626 1.061 .912 499 14 OAK Stairs .253 .384 .767 1.152 .352 .460 .776 1.237 1.211 497 15 ATL Tucker .303 .348 .341 .689 .309 .380 .567 .947 .869 482 16 BOS O'Leary .280 .333 .445 .778 .343 .361 .530 .891 .857 467 17 BAL Baines .291 .291 .502 .793 .351 .417 .525 .941 .897 457 18 CHW Martinez .283 .336 .483 .819 .321 .384 .397 .781 .793 454 19 FLA Daulton .233 .346 .471 .817 .270 .445 .543 .988 .937 451 20 MIN Lawton .255 .420 .374 .794 .206 .383 .414 .797 .796 436 21 SF Javier .267 .369 .386 .755 .333 .431 .415 .847 .819 418 22 TOR Green .314 .352 .365 .717 .308 .333 .601 .934 .869 409 23 CIN Sanders .372 .477 .839 1.316 .233 .354 .626 .980 1.081 387 24 BAL Hammonds .295 .355 .604 .958 .256 .318 .532 .850 .882 383 25 PIT Guillen .266 .286 .385 .671 .280 .300 .432 .732 .714 376 26 OAK Canseco .203 .315 .338 .653 .196 .337 .579 .916 .837 373 27 ATL Jones .308 .456 .625 1.080 .154 .287 .387 .674 .796 372 28 MTL Santangelo .257 .415 .336 .751 .213 .431 .410 .842 .814 358 29 MTL Guerrero .360 .395 .654 1.049 .361 .403 .572 .975 .997 353 30 SEA Kelly .316 .386 .576 .962 .297 .317 .481 .798 .847 337 31 TOR Merced .189 .302 .352 .653 .307 .409 .425 .834 .780 328 32 SF Hill .276 .309 .493 .802 .255 .276 .445 .721 .745 319 33 STL Mabry .244 .265 .277 .542 .318 .375 .377 .752 .689 299 34 DET Nieves .212 .306 .439 .745 .158 .236 .438 .674 .695 282 35 Shortstops vsLH vsRH TM Name AVG OBA SLG OPS AVG OBA SLG OPS Rate Bval PosR BOS Garciaparra .267 .287 .613 .900 .373 .396 .674 1.070 1.019 748 1 ATL Blauser .395 .569 .788 1.357 .375 .491 .538 1.028 1.127 702 2 NYY Jeter .321 .415 .435 .850 .328 .428 .470 .897 .883 661 3 KC Bell .248 .331 .323 .654 .350 .458 .611 1.069 .945 624 4 SEA Rodriguez .328 .359 .663 1.022 .340 .389 .538 .927 .956 610 5 MTL Grudzielanek .222 .244 .343 .586 .308 .327 .473 .800 .736 506 6 CLE Vizquel .273 .300 .388 .688 .304 .388 .402 .790 .759 487 7 FLA Renteria .258 .347 .274 .621 .306 .344 .375 .720 .690 477 8 STL Clayton .246 .260 .460 .721 .291 .311 .398 .709 .713 441 9 PIT Dunston .293 .300 .441 .741 .354 .360 .502 .862 .826 422 10 PHI Stocker .339 .419 .492 .910 .255 .304 .351 .655 .732 410 11 SF Vizcaino .219 .328 .258 .586 .271 .298 .378 .676 .649 409 12 SD Gomez .345 .479 .387 .866 .235 .313 .303 .616 .691 405 13 MIL Valentin .244 .258 .322 .580 .230 .287 .500 .787 .725 396 14 COL Weiss .148 .330 .247 .577 .289 .420 .474 .894 .799 375 15 MIN Meares .153 .216 .259 .475 .315 .366 .460 .826 .720 348 16 ANA DiSarcina .165 .181 .199 .380 .266 .280 .394 .674 .586 341 17 LA Gagne .262 .296 .398 .694 .244 .272 .279 .551 .594 329 18 TOR Gonzalez .263 .324 .394 .718 .207 .273 .355 .628 .655 313 19 COL Perez .350 .356 .593 .950 .290 .310 .488 .798 .843 290 20 CHW Guillen .243 .243 .380 .622 .198 .198 .303 .501 .537 283 21 BAL Bordick .129 .137 .164 .302 .247 .295 .291 .586 .501 281 22 HOU Gutierrez .261 .302 .386 .688 .282 .329 .430 .758 .737 241 23 DET Cruz .166 .166 .198 .364 .227 .227 .332 .559 .501 234 24 CIN Reese .117 .248 .195 .443 .212 .262 .295 .557 .523 228 25 TEX Gil .206 .317 .473 .790 .173 .181 .193 .373 .498 172 26 NYM Ordonez .234 .241 .238 .479 .141 .149 .199 .348 .387 151 27Comments are not only welcome, but highly encouraged. Back to the top of page | BTF Homepage |